This session we continued to run songs, discussing structure and arrangement. One of the important considerations as we begin to imagine the songs in production is the balance between sound and silence.
Context, as they say, is everything, and learning how to use silence to frame a melody and lyric can really bring out the most in a song. One proverb I came across sums it up well: words are silver but silence is golden. We frame the words with silence. Silence makes it sing.
In any case, working in the modern digital studio with hundreds of gorgeous sounds at your fingertips makes it very tempting to fill up the silence with a rich but unnecessary arrangement.
We know this and so we’ve been talking about how to strike a balance in the songs that will give them an interesting sonic texture that brings out the most of the melody and the lyrics. A golden frame for silver words, as it were. When does the lap steel come in? At the beginning or in the second verse? Does it play throughout, or only at one or two points in the song? Should we have backup vocals in this part? What about a tone wheel organ? Or nothing. Just a single note the guitar maybe. So many possibilities.
From a production standpoint, one approach may be to try out lots of different ideas and explore options before making decisions and stripping it to the essentials. But this still comes down to a subjective decision in the process, and one where experience and a sense of discipline will pay off in the end.